Updated plans have been submitted for the Lake Merritt BART redevelopment in Downtown Oakland, Alameda County. The application for the second half of Block One shows developers have shifted away from the 28-story tower with mostly market-rate housing to a fully affordable eight-story complex dubbed One Fallon. East Bay Asian Local Development Company is responsible for the application.

Lake Merritt BART redevelopment Block 1 site plan, illustration by Solomon Cordwell Buenz
The Lake Merritt BART redevelopment master plan was filed in tandem with EBALDC and Strada Investment Group. The master plan was initially filed to add four structures across two blocks. Construction is currently wrapping up for Building B on Block One. The new application would address the second half of Block One. Previously. Strada was expected to develop the site with a 28-story tower containing 360 apartments and ground-floor retail. Of the 360 units, 36 would be deed-restricted as affordable. The initial details for Block 2 included a 19-story office tower next to a seven-story housing complex with 100 affordable units.
The 85-foot-tall structure is expected to yield around 132,200 square feet, including 114,150 square feet of housing and 7,620 square feet of ground-level retail. Parking will be included for 60 bicycles and 17 vehicles. Unit sizes will vary with 12 studios, 43 one-bedrooms, 27 two-bedrooms, and 30 three-bedrooms. Of the 112 units, 62 will be deed-restricted as affordable to very low-income households, 49 for low-income households, and one market-rate apartment for the on-site property manager.

One Fallon facade elevation, rendering by Solomon Cordwell Buenz
The application invokes Assembly Bill 2011, Senate Bill 330, and the State Density Bonus law to streamline approval. While the project does not exceed the maximum base density of 176 units, the applicant still uses the State Density Bonus to achieve waivers and incentives related to ground-floor height and bulk control.
Solomon Cordwell Buenz is responsible for the design. Renderings show a familiar residential infill style with seven floors of vertical-patterned panels above a ground-floor level of cement plaster. The second floor will feature a podium-top terrace and an amenity flex room. The ground floor will include a garage, community room, residential services offices, and flex space facing the proposed paseo dividing the center of the block. Facade materials will include cement plaster, vertical-patterned panels, and metal.

Lake Merritt BART Senior Housing establishing view circa January 2026, image by Andrew Campbell Nelson
The 0.44-acre lot is located along 9th Street between Oak Street and Fallon Street. Future residents would live across from the PYATOK-designed seven-story affordable senior housing complex. Crews are nearing completion of the first structure within the transit-oriented development master plan. The block is adjacent to the plaza-capped BART Station and the expansive Laney College campus. The Oakland Museum of California is just over a block away.
The estimated cost and timeline for construction have not yet been shared.
Subscribe to YIMBY’s daily e-mail
![]()
Follow YIMBYgram for real-time photo updates
Like YIMBY on Facebook
Follow YIMBY’s Twitter for the latest in YIMBYnews






Well, that’s a stupid downgrade.
BART slowly but surely running all chances to get some financial gains from its parking lot redevelopments. Instead of added revenue, it’s going to be money sinks.
Ruining all*
Thanks Apple autocorrect 🙃
Yes, yes, yes, we all know that the YIMBRO cartel despises low-income housing. It’s gotta be market rate for the bros, no?
It’s almost 100% affordable housing development across Oakland for the past 3-4 years. We need diversity in development.
McWiener, I guess every country with an extensive and highly utilized public transit system is wrong about how they tie TOD to funding their massively successful mass transit systems? Do some research, bro. Also, EBALDC allegedly intimidated residents at their San Pablo Hotel property to stop them from forming a tenants’ union, so their development plans might not actually have the ideological basis you think they do.
Newsflash. YIMBY likes fiscal responsibility. They especially like equal opportunity and believe younger generations should not be ball-and-chained by the failures of generations born in the last half-century and beyond.
But NOOOOOOOO
This a**hole believes Prop 13 is scared text, and the do-nothingness mentality is why San Jose has the charm of a Texas exurb, and Oakland isn’t allowed to evolve beyond anything but concentrated poverty.
Wanna clutch some more pearls on the Marina Safeway, which would provide more affordable housing in that chunk of SF since the North Point Towers topped out in 1963. And even then, these were never marketed as affordable, just dense.
Should we revisit the stat that the Marina produced only 14 affordable units from 2005 to 2026?
So here is an opportunity for the many “poors” who rely on BART to keep running, without forcing more taxes to be squeezed out of them by Ballot Measures approved last night. Regular funding keeps the lights on. Maximizing density on scarce land prevents displacement elsewhere.
Do you ever, just once, think about the words you sh*t out, or are you just this gifted in a**holery?
Drewl, you need to lay off the coffee brah.
Spare me the sob story about all the poor young people in the Bay Area. You guys are all a bunch of overpaid, underperforming nitwits. Quit whining and buy your own feckin’ house.
By the way, I don’t care if they build that thing on the Marina Safeway because I never go to the Marina because it’s full of awful people like you.
That’s your reply? 😂
That… is your reply?
You don’t even live in Oakland why do you care bud, 9am and you don’t have anything else better to do with your time geeeez
agree.
8 stories??? What are we doing here guys
For folks wondering why it’s been “downgraded” it’s because the new construction condo market in Oakland is in the friggin toilet
There’s not enough demand for a 28-story tower of market rate units here, nor a silly 19-story office tower on the adjacent block. We should be happy this is getting built the way it is with a high emphasis on senior and affordable housing.
BART should spearhead the development and treat it as an investment. Don’t take no as an answer.
BART *is* spearheading the development by building an affordable housing mid-rise. There isn’t private or public funding available for towers right now, especially with current interest rates and tariffs.
Totally understood but, what a wasted opportunity from an urban planning point-of-view.
Wasted opportunity. If the whole issue is affordable housing, they can build 500 units and make more than 112 of them affordable. 🤦♂️
That’s not the whole issue. The “whole issue” is that the bottom has fallen out of the condo market in Oakland, and new commercial office space is also not worth building. The downtown construction boom of the late 2010s has produced a surplus. How many “ground floor retail” spaces in new condo construction are actually occupied? I’d guess fewer than half
ground floor retail hasn’t worked in oakland for years.
That’s part of my point here
Yep, this is the largest project that funding is available for. We need more funding for housing either via bonds or a public bank to build higher.
EBALDC needs to be investigated
This is really stupid and should actually be blocked. If condo sales arent great then let them be rentals. Its literally on bart. I keep reading about how rent is up in the city. Stick to the original design and net more housing. Redesign the office tower if necessary but that market will change soon enough.
agree. SF Ai commercial will be drifting over soon enough.
Well this is a big downgrade from 360 units on only 112 units. I’m all for low income housing, but a net loss for 250 units doesn’t feel like the right call.
Couldn’t they keep the 360 units plan and set aside the 112 units? Is that’s not affordable, build taller, cut parking, shrink # of 3bed units?
So we are going to under utilize a prime location because the market is down? This is so short sighted. If they developer isn’t going to use this property to it’s fullest extent then they shouldn’t be building here. It’s not like we are going to get a redo in 5 years when the Oakland housing market recovers.
Following their logic, let’s reduce the speed limit on highways because gas prices are high.
Such a shame we lost 500 units because of a stupidity. I agree with others that it could’ve been a tower with units for rent.
>>> Following their logic, let’s reduce the speed limit on highways because gas prices are high.
If you study history, you would know that is actually the precise reason why a national 55mph speed limit was put in place in 1974 – as a direct response to the OPEC oil embargo that had fuel prices skyrocketing.
From wikipedia entry for “National Maximum Speed Law”:
As an emergency response to the 1973 oil crisis, on November 26, 1973, President Richard Nixon proposed a national 50 mph (80 km/h) speed limit for passenger vehicles and a 55 mph (89 km/h) speed limit for trucks and buses. In response to Nixon’s proposal, the National Maximum Speed Limit (NMSL) was enacted in the 1974 Emergency Highway Energy Conservation Act that withheld Federal Highway funds from states that refused to comply with provisions of the law, including a maximum speed limit of 55 miles per hour (89 km/h) for passenger vehicles, an increase Nixon approved in signing the final legislation.
BART will continue to fail if stumble along blindly with the concept of housing associated with BART stations. Not sure what the incentive is for such fever to build housing clustered at BART stations. I wonder has a study been done to determine the percentage of people living in those BART related housing developments who actually use BART. More funds need to go into the lateral transportation systems that feed Bart from the outline areas bought in Oakland is basically a east to west transit line. More people in Oakland live North of that path, how does BART incentivize those people to consider bought an inviable transportation medium? Well, one way is to provide North South dedicated transportation, similar to the Emeryville Go Round, to provide North-South travel to and from BART stations! That’s how to increase ridership without having to beg so much.
There are basically two near-term options here:
1) Build the subsidized affordable housing, providing needed housing now
2) Leave it a parking lot and hope a future development cycle is able to build a high-rise. No bank is going to lend money for a residential high-rise in Oakland right now when many of the recent ones have been foreclosed because they can’t charge rents high enough to pay back their loans.
I’d choose #1 because there are plenty of other lots downtown that can be developed in the future, although admittedly not right on top of BART.
That said, they really need to fix that sad blank wall at street level along 9th St. Blank facades at pedestrian level shouldn’t be allowed downtown.
Finally someone using common sense.
The perfect is the enemy of the good. Just look at SF –all of the housing blocked in the 2010s because it wasn’t “perfect” just became empty lots and unfinished holes. 112 units is still a lot better than 0.
Also, to the people saying “just build taller” — the problem is money. Taller buildings are more expensive. Eight stories is the max that anyone is building in the current economic climate, because construction costs jump nonlinearly past that point.
This is much more than perfection being an enemy of good; this is long-term structural financing for BART.
The world is still building tall. Even SF is picking up again, with a handful of towers entering construction soon and other major proposals now possible under new housing laws.
If the timing isn’t right, wait. Oakland has been frozen for long enough. Various chunks are seeing new life, and I welcome the change that’s come near MacArthur, West Oakland, East Oakland, etc. But this is a RARE opportunity to add positive money to BART without a new sales or property tax. I voted bitterly for the RTM measure. They do need financing that isn’t ticket-based, but now everyone’s livelihood is getting just another step more unaffordable. I hope a stronger foundation sees positive impact…
Yes, we need more affordable options, but we also need more self-sustaining infrastructure that doesn’t bleed us dry. We can only tax the rich so much when fixing our other shortcomings.
We should actually try taxing the rich for once.
Ugly af.
Nice looking building but huge downgrade. There is way too much 100% affordable housing being built. W need a mix of affordable and market rate housing. The original plan was much better
“market-rate housing to a fully affordable”
Something is broken as there is no profit in building market rate. All these projects need low income housing subsidies